The SeaDoc Society is a program of the Wildlife Health Center at the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine.
Share 

Derelict fishing gear


Net Gains: The Economics of Removing Derelict Fishing Gear

derelict fishing netRestoring a vast, complex ecosystem like the Salish Sea costs money — that long green stuff with the short future. With politicians and public opinion involved, tough fights often break out over spending on improvements that, to some, appear subjective: Is it worth $100,000 to remove a certain bulkhead or replant a certain eel grass bed? Maybe… And that’s where good science can inform great policy.

One of the best examples of science coming to the rescue of a dollar-and-cents conservation issue occurred when the SeaDoc Society recently got caught up in the question of abandoned fishing nets. In partnership with the Northwest Straits Initiative, SeaDoc developed a predictive model that clearly shows the cost of these ghost nets that continue to trap and kill marine life for decades.

northwest straits logoNorthwest Straits Initiative-funded researchers made multiple dives on derelict nets, counting trapped critters, studying decomposition rates, and determining how much of the dead marine life fell out of the nets as they were recovered (Over 17% of the catch never made it to the surface, showing how critical it is to have underwater scientists on the job). SeaDoc then dove into the data, actually inventing a statistical model to predict each cast-off net’s killing capacity.

The results? Abandoned nets catch and kill more than 1,000 invertebrates (mainly crabs), 150 fish, and nearly 80 birds every year, year after year after year – and most of these silent killers have been doing their dirty work since the 1970s. Run that data through the seafood value calculator and it quickly adds up, with each net wasting $19,656 in Dungeness crab alone, every 10 years. The one-time cost to retrieve a derelict net? $1,358. It doesn’t take an accountant to do that cost-benefit analysis.

Only through funding from private donors like you was SeaDoc able to do this ground-breaking (and net-cutting) science, which has led to clear policy and, more importantly, vital and measurable improvement in the Salish Sea ecosystem. Thank you.

To view the manuscript just published in Marine Pollution Bulletin, click here (pdf).

For more about SeaDoc's derelict fishing gear project, see our lost fishing gear page.

Please share this Wildlife Post with your network using the button below to post on social media sharing sites or send an email with a link to this page.

Marine species mortality in derelict fishing nets in Puget Sound, WA and the cost/benefits of derelict net removal

Gilardi, K.V.K., D. Carlson-Bremer, J.A. June, K. Antonelis, G. Broadhurst, T. Cowan. 2009. Marine species mortality in derelict fishing nets in Puget Sound, WA and the cost/benefits of derelict net removal. Marine Pollution Bulletin 60 (2010) 376–382. Full text available at www.elsevier.com/locate/marpolbul

Derelict Fishing Gear Study

Derelict fishing gear—lost, abandoned or discarded sport and commercial line, nets, traps, etc.—in the marine environment is a significant cause of injury in California coastal marine wildlife. We evaluated data for stranded animals only; our results may underestimate the true number of coastal marine animals injured by lost or discarded fishing gear in California.

Research by SeaDoc Director Kirsten Gilardi and others has studied the medical records from certain wildlife rehabilitation facilities in California to determine the rate and timing of injuries from derelict fishing gear.

Get the full citation and download information.

Fishing gear-related injury in California Marine Wildlife

Kaplan Dau,B., K. V. K. Gilardi, F. M. Gulland, A. Higgins, J. B. Holcomb, J. St. Leger, and M. H. Ziccardi. 2009. Fishing gear-related injury in California Marine Wildlife. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 45: 355–362. Download PDF.

Joe Gaydos reappointed to Northwest Straits Commission

In January of 2009, SeaDoc Society Regional Director Joe Gaydos was reappointed to the Northwest Straits Commission by Governor Christine Gregoire. This is his second four-year term.

Get more details http://www.pnwlocalnews.com/sanjuans/isj/news/37490414.html">here.

One derelict fishing net: 3500 animals killed

A recent study by the Northwest Straits Initiative has shown that kill rates for derelict fishing gear are much higher than was understood. Animals caught in the nets decompose in as little as ten days. One of the monitored nets is now estimated to have killed some 2,300 fish and 1,200 marine birds in the 15 years it's been in the water.

SeaDoc Society Regional Director Joe Gaydos is quoted in the article. Gaydos is also a member of the Northwest Straits Commission.

Read the full story in the San Juan Journal online, or download the full report of the study, "Rates of Marine Species Mortality Caused by Derelict Fishing Nets in Puget Sound, Washington"

Lost Fishing Gear

LOST FISHING GEAR RECOVERY PROJECT

derelict fishing netLost fishing gear is commercial and recreational fishing gear -- nets, traps, pots, line -- that becomes lost or is discarded in the water. The gear ends up sitting on the sea floor, getting caught on rocky reefs, or floating in the water column. The majority of this lost gear does not decompose in seawater and can remain in the marine environment for years.

Lost gear impacts the marine environment in several ways: it can continue to "catch" marine animals, which become entangled or trapped; it can damage the habitat upon which it becomes entangled or upon which it rests; it can pose an underwater hazard for boaters, entangling boat propellers and anchors; and it can similarly endanger humans, especially divers. Lost gear is also a visual blight, diminishing the natural aesthetic quality of the seafloor and rocky reef habitat for underwater enthusiasts.

Net being removed from California watersThe SeaDoc Society at the University of California, Davis Wildlife Health Center launched the California Lost Fishing Gear Recovery Project in July 2005 in partnership with the California Ocean Protection Council and State Coastal Conservancy, the Northwest Straits Commission (Mt. Vernon, Washington), and NOAA's Marine Debris Program and Office of Restoration. This project encourages ocean users to report the presence of lost gear, and hires experienced and certified SCUBA divers to remove gear from near-shore waters in a safe and environmentally sensitive manner.

retrieving a derelict potSince May 2006, the California Lost Fishing Gear Recovery Project has retrieved nearly 11 tons of gear from around the California Channel Islands (Santa Rosa, Santa Cruz, Anacapa and Santa Catalina). As well, the project has cleaned more than 1400 pounds of recreational fishing gear off public fishing piers from Santa Cruz to Imperial Beach including more than 1 million feet of fishing line. Several of these piers now have fishing line recycling bins, to encourage proper disposal of unwanted hooks and microfilament.

monofilament and hook recycling bin

In 2008-2010, with the support of the California Wildlife ConservationBoard and the NOAA Marine Debris Program, the California Lost Fishing Gear Recovery Project plans to help reduce the potential impact of lost fishing gear on living marine resources and underwater habitat by building upon successes to date to accomplish the following new goals:

  • Enhance the function and restore underwater habitat of the Central Coast Marine Protected Areas by focusing gear recovery effort in this newly-established MPA network.
  • Expand the recreational fishing gear recovery effort and voluntary fishing gear recycling program to more public-access marine fishing piers and to the charter fishing vessel fleets in Central and Southern California, working toward turn-over of these programs long-term to citizen volunteer groups and the commercial charter industry;
  • Retrieve lost fishing gear anywhere on the coast where it is a high priority for removal because of demonstrated or potential impacts to marine wildlife and people, including more work in the Channel Islands Marine Sanctuary; and
  • Increase the likelihood that ocean users and enthusiasts will know enough about the project and the issue to serve as our "eyes" on and under the water through outreach.

If you have lost fishing gear or if you have encountered or seen lost fishing gear and would like to file a report, please:

To download a copy of the California Lost Fishing Gear Recovery Project Policies & Procedures manual (pdf), please click here.

If you have questions about lost fishing gear removal or for copies of our field reports, contact staff:

 

Kirsten Gilardi photo
Kirsten Gilardi
kvgilardi@ucdavis.edu
Jennifer Renzullo photo
Jennifer Renzullo
jrrenzullo@ucdavis.edu



Sign up for our newsletter to get monthly updates on our activities and accomplishments.
  Required information:
* Email
  Optional information:

If you include your name and address we'll send you two free SeaDoc stickers so you can show people you care about healthy oceans. Plus you'll get hard copy versions of our Wildlife Posts six times a year.

First Name
Last Name
Address
City
State
Zip
Please send me reminders of SeaDoc events
I'm a SCUBA diver
 

Why our work matters

Healthy ecosystems support economic prosperity. The Salish Sea provides abundant natural capital that contributes substantially to the financial prosperity of the region. Unhealthy ecosystems cost money because we lose the opportunity to benefit from them. The Salish Sea's deteriorating health threatens our economic well being and quality of life. SeaDoc uses science to find solutions to the problems facing the fish, wildlife and people of the Salish Sea.

How you can help:

Make a donation: Most of SeaDoc's work is supported by private donations from people like you who care about the health of our coastal ecosystems. Your donation makes it possible for us to keep doing the science that will give us objective information about designing a healthy ecosystem that benefits both people and wildlife. Click here to learn more about donating to SeaDoc.


Adminstrator login | Sign up for our Email Newsletter | Make a Donation